Best Pizza in Evansville

Q: Where are you located?

We are located in Evansville, IN at 510 W Mill Rd

Family-Owned Pizza Serving Fresh Classics Since 1986

Order online

Featured

View menu

Welcome to Rounders Pizza

Welcome to Rounders Pizza, a family-owned pizza restaurant serving the community since 1986. Located north of the city at 510 West Mill Road, we’ve been in the same building from the start. Known for our well-loved nameless pizza and fresh daily prep, we serve classic pies made with care. Enjoy dine-in, takeout, or delivery in a cozy, full-service setting that locals trust and families return to week after week. 🍕

Family Owned. Community Focused.

Rounders Pizza is run by a close-knit family, with a father, daughter, and son working side by side every day. The restaurant was taken over in 2011 and has been proudly operated by the same family for 14 years. Staying true to its roots, Rounders Pizza continues to serve guests in the same location, building strong connections with locals while keeping quality and consistency at the center of everything we do.

Learn Our Story

Classic Pizzas Locals Love

Our menu is built around pizzas that keep guests coming back, led by our popular supreme pizza and the well-known nameless pizza. Every pie is prepared fresh daily using carefully selected ingredients. Along with pizzas, the menu includes a variety of sides and classic favorites that pair well with any meal. Whether dining in or ordering to go, Rounders Pizza keeps the focus on quality, balance, and familiar flavors. 🍕

Explore Our Menu

More Variety, Same Quality

Rounders Pizza serves more than just pizza. Our menu also includes hot subs, sandwiches, wings, fries, and a variety of appetizers made fresh daily. You’ll also find salads, breaded sides, desserts, and kid-friendly options that make meals easy for families and groups. These items pair well with our pizzas or stand strong on their own, giving guests more ways to enjoy a complete and satisfying meal any time they visit.

Simple Ordering, Your Way

Ordering from Rounders Pizza is quick and easy, whether you choose delivery, takeout, or dine-in. Our online ordering system lets you place your order directly from our website with just a few steps. Skip the wait and order ahead to enjoy fresh pizza prepared daily, ready when you need it. Perfect for busy days, family meals, or casual dinners at home.

Order Now

A look inside Rounders Pizza

Take a look at our pizzas and more. Our gallery highlights the food that guests enjoy every day. 📸

Save Your Seat Ahead

Reservations are available at Rounders Pizza for guests who prefer to plan ahead. Whether it’s a family dinner, a small group, or a special occasion, booking a table helps ensure a smooth visit. Our friendly team is happy to assist with reservation requests and seating needs, making your dine-in experience comfortable from the moment you arrive.

Save Your Seat

Good Pours, Great Viewing

Our restaurant features six beer taps available for guests dining in, adding to a relaxed and social atmosphere. A TV is available in the dining area so guests can watch games or local events while enjoying their meal. The space is casual and comfortable, making it a great place to gather with friends, spend time with family, or enjoy a laid-back dine-in experience.

Plan Your Party

Our restaurant offers a comfortable space for private parties and group gatherings. We can host family celebrations, team dinners, and special occasions in a relaxed setting that feels welcoming and easy. When needed, the restaurant can close early to give your group a more private experience. With attentive service and a menu that works well for sharing, your event stays simple, organized, and enjoyable from start to finish. 🎉

Inquire Now

Your Neighborhood Pizza Spot

📍 Address: 510 West Mill Road 🕒 Hours: Monday: Closed Tuesday: 11 am–2 pm, 4–9 pm Wednesday: 11 am–2 pm, 4–9 pm Thursday: 11 am–2 pm, 4–9 pm Friday: 11 am–2 pm, 4–10 pm Saturday: 4–9 pm Sunday: 4–9 pm 🍕 Family-owned, full-service dining.

Get Directions

We've been regulars for a number of years now. There is not a better tasting marinara sauce around, which to me, makes the pizza. The Viv, and potato pizza are ours favorites, but everything on the menu is superb. The service and camaraderie from Dave, Kevin, and Heather keep us coming back.

Sarah B.

Great pizza at great prices. Best hot ham and cheese in town. The Nameless pizza is a must have. Rounders is a great carry out place, but eating in is the way to go! They've got nice, big TVs and they've got excellent finger bread that goes great with an ice cold pitcher of beer. We also found out their salads are massive and delicious. Lastly, the owner and his staff are kind, personable, and work their tails off.

Benton F.

This place is definately worth stopping off for if you enjoy great pizza and awsome friendliness truck parking in back limited though but available...will definately be back to see this place for sure 👍 🤔 👌 🙂 😀 😌

Hector P.

Featuring

Delivery

Takeout

Dine-In

Reservation

Outdoor Seating

Vegetarian Options

Good for Watching Sport

Rounders Pizza Rewards

Join our rewards program, earn points every time you order online, and redeem your points for free food!

Join Rounders Pizza Rewards

Frequently Asked Questions

What are you known for?

We’re known for pizza with meat, veggie, and chicken toppings, plus stromboli sandwiches, boneless wings, salads, and sweet finishes in Evansville.

American Food: American favorites span specialty pizzas, chicken baskets, hearty sandwiches, and snacks like soft pretzels and nachos with cheese. Examples include Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza, Chicken Strip Basket, B.B.C. Beef Bacon and Cheddar Sandwich, Soft Pretzels, and Nachos & Cheese.
Italian Food: Italian-inspired options bring together meat and vegetable pizzas, stromboli sandwiches, feta bread, and chicken Parmesan sandwiches. Examples include Meat Pizza, Veggie Pizza, Stromboli Sandwich, Feta Bread, and Chicken Parmesan Sandwich.
Sandwiches: Sandwich options cover hot ham and cheese, chicken, Italian subs, French dips, and vegetable or taco-style stromboli. Examples include Hot Ham and Cheese Dressed Sandwich, Chicken Parmesan Sandwich, Italian Submarine Sandwich, French Dip Sandwich, Veggie Stromboli Sandwich, and Taco Stromboli Sandwich.
Pizza: Pizza ranges from customizable combinations to meat, veggie, Buffalo chicken, taco, and potato varieties. Examples include Create Your Own Pizza, Meat Pizza, Veggie Pizza, Buffalo Chicken Pizza, Taco Pizza, and Potato Pizza.
Chicken: Chicken comes in strip baskets, boneless wings, crispy salads, sandwiches, and Buffalo-style pizza. Examples include Chicken Strip Basket, Boneless Wings, Crispy Chicken Salad, Chicken Bacon Ranch Sandwich, and Buffalo Chicken Pizza.

Additionally, explore Hoagies, Salads, Stromboli, and Desserts.

What meals do you serve?

We serve Lunch and Dinner

Do you offer delivery or takeout?

Yes, we offer Delivery and Takeout

Where are you located?

We are located in Evansville, IN at 510 W Mill Rd

What areas do you serve?

We serve the following areas: Country Club Meadows, North Park, Stringtown, Highland, Kratzville, Harwood, North Country Club, Diamond-Stringtown, and Darmstadt.

Anything else?

We are also known for Family Friendly Restaurant